Showing posts with label illegal immigration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label illegal immigration. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 19, 2013

Opinion: Putting a perverse publicity stunt in perspective

Students at UT Austin



 In the continuing learning process of how to act in a changing society, a conservative group at the University of Texas’ flagship university in Austin got a lesson in humility it will surely want to forget.

Young Conservatives of Texas were to hold a “Catch an Illegal Immigrant” event this week, where club members would wander around campus “wearing signs that say, ‘illegal immigrant’, and students who capture them and take them to the Young Conservatives’ recruiting tables will get $25 gift certificates”.

This level of diaper-wearing attention-seeking by the group’s chairman, Lorenzo Garcia, would be embarrassing enough to any parent. Yet Garcia was desperately seeking attention for his sick publicity stunt, and the media gave Garcia what he was looking for.  A story on the prospect of “an illegal immigrant hunt” was bound to get clicks, so the media gave Garcia what he was looking for.

Yet it’s important in a democratic society to respond to the littleness of such ideas precisely because of its privileged source.

Insensitivity to human suffering is one thing, and promoting policies that needlessly contribute to human suffering is yet another. But reveling in that suffering by mocking those caught in the claws of our immigration system is a level of sociopathic behavior that can only be matched by the irony of the event being held at a university of immense privilege, in fact already a majority-minority school, by a kid with a Hispanic surname.

In fact, the same kid recently held an affirmative action bake sale.  Students were sold baked goods on a price scale where minorities paid less than whites and Asians, the message being that whites and Asians are being discriminated against by affirmative action policies.

One wonders what access to privilege students like Garcia are yearning for when the median wealth of whites is almost twenty times that of blacks, and whites outpace blacks in almost any socio-economic measurement imaginable.  Acknowledging our history of discrimination against minority groups is a small gesture by institutions of higher learning to consider in the admissions process, and the current gauntlet of depravity thrown at minority communities known as the “war on drugs” is yet another reason to fight for comprehensive admissions policies.

Our immigration policy is but another system of control over minorities, most of which who come here as a result of American foreign policy decisions that are impoverishing the homes of the immigrants among us we now resent, and Mr. Garcia finds so much joy in his perverse publicity stunt.

The response by the Greg Abbot for Governor campaign was to rightfully call this a “repugnant effort” and to distance itself from the Young Conservatives leader.

Garcia was forced to cancel the event when the President of UT-Austin voiced his denunciation of the young conservatives’ proposed stunt and the Office of Diversity and Community Engagement objected to the event by calling it a violation of the student honor code.

Fortunately, wiser heads prevailed, but only because social media and our institutions of information compelled others into the admission that the sources of power are changing.

Lesson learned, for now.

Opinion: Putting a perverse publicity stunt in perspective     stephen nuno nbc final e1370610376199 news NBC Latino News
Stephen A. Nuño, Ph.D., NBC Latino contributor and an Assistant Professor in the Department of Politics and International Affairs at Northern Arizona University. He is currently writing a book on Republican outreach into the Latino Community.


Tuesday, June 25, 2013

Marco Rubio Follows in Charlie Crist’s Immigration Footsteps





By Javier Manjarres

Like Charlie Crist, Senator Marco Rubio was against amnesty for illegal immigrants, before he was for it.

Before...

Marco Rubio - "No, no - never have been. In fact, I'm strongly against amnesty...So I am not and I will never support - never have and never support - any effort to grant blanket, legalization amnesty who have entered or stayed in this country illegally." Shark Tank video


Charlie Crist - "It's certainly worth a very good debate and research," Crist said. "If there are people here that aren't paying into the system, which everyone agrees there are, that's in essence a form of fraud on the system," Crist said he doesn't support amnesty." - (circa 1998)


Now....

Charlie Crist - Talking to reporters afterwards, he said he would support an immigration bill similar to the failed 2007 legislation that many Republicans  opposed because it provided a path to citizenship for illegal immigrants. President George W. Bush, eventual Republican presidential nominee John McCain and Martinez supported the measure.

"I like Sen. Martinez' and Sen. McCain's approach," Crist said. "I thought they had the right idea and maybe just a little more support up here would help it get it done." -(May 19, 2009 - AP)

Marco Rubio - "Gang of Eight" immigration reform bill (2013)
By JAVIER MANJARRES Like Charlie Crist, Senator Marco Rubio was against amnesty for illegal immigrants, before he was for it. Before… Marco Rubio-“No, no – never have been. In fact, I’m strongly against amnesty… So I am not and I will never support – never have and never will support — any effort to grant blanket, legalization amnesty to folks who have entered or stayed in this country illegally.”-Shark Tank video Charlie Crist- ”It’s certainly worth a very good debate and research,” Crist said. “If there are people here that aren’t paying into the system, which everyone agrees there are, that’s in essence a form of fraud on the system.” Crist said he doesn’t support amnesty.”-(circa 1998) Now… Charlie Crist-Talking to reporters afterward, he said he would support an immigration bill similar to the failed 2007 legislation that many Republicans opposed because it provided a path to citizenship for illegal immigrants. President George W. Bush, eventual Republican presidential nominee John McCain and Martinez supported the measure. “I like Sen. Martinez’ and Sen. McCain’s approach,” Crist said. “I thought they had the right idea and maybe just a little more support up there would help it get it done.”-(May19, 2009-AP) Marco Rubio- “Gang of Eight” immigration reform bill (2013) - See more at: http://shark-tank.net/2013/06/25/marco-rubio-follows-in-charlie-crists-immigration-footsteps/#sthash.oob6ow5E.SpRrVZ6h.dpuf

Read more at: http://shark-tank.net/2013/06/25/marco-rubio-follows-in-charlie-crists-immigration-footsteps/ | The Shark Tank

By JAVIER MANJARRES Like Charlie Crist, Senator Marco Rubio was against amnesty for illegal immigrants, before he was for it. Before… Marco Rubio-“No, no – never have been. In fact, I’m strongly against amnesty… So I am not and I will never support – never have and never will support — any effort to grant blanket, legalization amnesty to folks who have entered or stayed in this country illegally.”-Shark Tank video Charlie Crist- ”It’s certainly worth a very good debate and research,” Crist said. “If there are people here that aren’t paying into the system, which everyone agrees there are, that’s in essence a form of fraud on the system.” Crist said he doesn’t support amnesty.”-(circa 1998) Now… Charlie Crist-Talking to reporters afterward, he said he would support an immigration bill similar to the failed 2007 legislation that many Republicans opposed because it provided a path to citizenship for illegal immigrants. President George W. Bush, eventual Republican presidential nominee John McCain and Martinez supported the measure. “I like Sen. Martinez’ and Sen. McCain’s approach,” Crist said. “I thought they had the right idea and maybe just a little more support up there would help it get it done.”-(May19, 2009-AP) Marco Rubio- “Gang of Eight” immigration reform bill (2013) - See more at: http://shark-tank.net/2013/06/25/marco-rubio-follows-in-charlie-crists-immigration-footsteps/#sthash.oob6ow5E.SpRrVZ6h.dpuf

Read more at: http://shark-tank.net/2013/06/25/marco-rubio-follows-in-charlie-crists-immigration-footsteps/ | The Shark Tank
By JAVIER MANJARRES Like Charlie Crist, Senator Marco Rubio was against amnesty for illegal immigrants, before he was for it. Before… Marco Rubio-“No, no – never have been. In fact, I’m strongly against amnesty… So I am not and I will never support – never have and never will support — any effort to grant blanket, legalization amnesty to folks who have entered or stayed in this country illegally.”-Shark Tank video Charlie Crist- ”It’s certainly worth a very good debate and research,” Crist said. “If there are people here that aren’t paying into the system, which everyone agrees there are, that’s in essence a form of fraud on the system.” Crist said he doesn’t support amnesty.”-(circa 1998) Now… Charlie Crist-Talking to reporters afterward, he said he would support an immigration bill similar to the failed 2007 legislation that many Republicans opposed because it provided a path to citizenship for illegal immigrants. President George W. Bush, eventual Republican presidential nominee John McCain and Martinez supported the measure. “I like Sen. Martinez’ and Sen. McCain’s approach,” Crist said. “I thought they had the right idea and maybe just a little more support up there would help it get it done.”-(May19, 2009-AP) Marco Rubio- “Gang of Eight” immigration reform bill (2013) - See more at: http://shark-tank.net/2013/06/25/marco-rubio-follows-in-charlie-crists-immigration-footsteps/#sthash.oob6ow5E.SpRrVZ6h.dpuf

Read more at: http://shark-tank.net/2013/06/25/marco-rubio-follows-in-charlie-crists-immigration-footsteps/ | The Shark Tank



Like Charlie Crist, Senator Marco Rubio was against amnesty for illegal immigrants, before he was for it. Before… Marco Rubio-“No, no – never have been. In fact, I’m strongly against amnesty… So I am not and I will never support – never have and never will support — any effort to grant blanket, legalization amnesty to folks who have entered or stayed in this country illegally.”-Shark Tank video Charlie Crist- ”It’s certainly worth a very good debate and research,” Crist said. “If there are people here that aren’t paying into the system, which everyone agrees there are, that’s in essence a form of fraud on the system.” Crist said he doesn’t support amnesty.”-(circa 1998) Now… Charlie Crist-Talking to reporters afterward, he said he would support an immigration bill similar to the failed 2007 legislation that many Republicans opposed because it provided a path to citizenship for illegal immigrants. President George W. Bush, eventual Republican presidential nominee John McCain and Martinez supported the measure. “I like Sen. Martinez’ and Sen. McCain’s approach,” Crist said. “I thought they had the right idea and maybe just a little more support up there would help it get it done.”-(May19, 2009-AP) Marco Rubio- “Gang of Eight” immigration reform bill (2013) - See more at: http://shark-tank.net/2013/06/25/marco-rubio-follows-in-charlie-crists-immigration-footsteps/#sthash.oob6ow5E.SpRrVZ6h.dpuf

Read more at: http://shark-tank.net/2013/06/25/marco-rubio-follows-in-charlie-crists-immigration-footsteps/ | The Shark Tank
By JAVIER MANJARRES Like Charlie Crist, Senator Marco Rubio was against amnesty for illegal immigrants, before he was for it. Before… Marco Rubio-“No, no – never have been. In fact, I’m strongly against amnesty… So I am not and I will never support – never have and never will support — any effort to grant blanket, legalization amnesty to folks who have entered or stayed in this country illegally.”-Shark Tank video Charlie Crist- ”It’s certainly worth a very good debate and research,” Crist said. “If there are people here that aren’t paying into the system, which everyone agrees there are, that’s in essence a form of fraud on the system.” Crist said he doesn’t support amnesty.”-(circa 1998) Now… Charlie Crist-Talking to reporters afterward, he said he would support an immigration bill similar to the failed 2007 legislation that many Republicans opposed because it provided a path to citizenship for illegal immigrants. President George W. Bush, eventual Republican presidential nominee John McCain and Martinez supported the measure. “I like Sen. Martinez’ and Sen. McCain’s approach,” Crist said. “I thought they had the right idea and maybe just a little more support up there would help it get it done.”-(May19, 2009-AP) Marco Rubio- “Gang of Eight” immigration reform bill (2013) - See more at: http://shark-tank.net/2013/06/25/marco-rubio-follows-in-charlie-crists-immigration-footsteps/#sthash.oob6ow5E.SpRrVZ6h.dpuf

Read more at: http://shark-tank.net/2013/06/25/marco-rubio-follows-in-charlie-crists-immigration-footsteps/ | The Shark Tank
By JAVIER MANJARRES Like Charlie Crist, Senator Marco Rubio was against amnesty for illegal immigrants, before he was for it. Before… Marco Rubio-“No, no – never have been. In fact, I’m strongly against amnesty… So I am not and I will never support – never have and never will support — any effort to grant blanket, legalization amnesty to folks who have entered or stayed in this country illegally.”-Shark Tank video Charlie Crist- ”It’s certainly worth a very good debate and research,” Crist said. “If there are people here that aren’t paying into the system, which everyone agrees there are, that’s in essence a form of fraud on the system.” Crist said he doesn’t support amnesty.”-(circa 1998) Now… Charlie Crist-Talking to reporters afterward, he said he would support an immigration bill similar to the failed 2007 legislation that many Republicans opposed because it provided a path to citizenship for illegal immigrants. President George W. Bush, eventual Republican presidential nominee John McCain and Martinez supported the measure. “I like Sen. Martinez’ and Sen. McCain’s approach,” Crist said. “I thought they had the right idea and maybe just a little more support up there would help it get it done.”-(May19, 2009-AP) Marco Rubio- “Gang of Eight” immigration reform bill (2013) - See more at: http://shark-tank.net/2013/06/25/marco-rubio-follows-in-charlie-crists-immigration-footsteps/#sthash.oob6ow5E.SpRrVZ6h.dpuf

Read more at: http://shark-tank.net/2013/06/25/marco-rubio-follows-in-charlie-crists-immigration-footsteps/ | The Shark Tank
By JAVIER MANJARRES Like Charlie Crist, Senator Marco Rubio was against amnesty for illegal immigrants, before he was for it. Before… Marco Rubio-“No, no – never have been. In fact, I’m strongly against amnesty… So I am not and I will never support – never have and never will support — any effort to grant blanket, legalization amnesty to folks who have entered or stayed in this country illegally.”-Shark Tank video Charlie Crist- ”It’s certainly worth a very good debate and research,” Crist said. “If there are people here that aren’t paying into the system, which everyone agrees there are, that’s in essence a form of fraud on the system.” Crist said he doesn’t support amnesty.”-(circa 1998) Now… Charlie Crist-Talking to reporters afterward, he said he would support an immigration bill similar to the failed 2007 legislation that many Republicans opposed because it provided a path to citizenship for illegal immigrants. President George W. Bush, eventual Republican presidential nominee John McCain and Martinez supported the measure. “I like Sen. Martinez’ and Sen. McCain’s approach,” Crist said. “I thought they had the right idea and maybe just a little more support up there would help it get it done.”-(May19, 2009-AP) Marco Rubio- “Gang of Eight” immigration reform bill (2013) - See more at: http://shark-tank.net/2013/06/25/marco-rubio-follows-in-charlie-crists-immigration-footsteps/#sthash.oob6ow5E.SpRrVZ6h.dpuf

Read more at: http://shark-tank.net/2013/06/25/marco-rubio-follows-in-charlie-crists-immigration-footsteps/ | The Shark Tank